Shorts might seem like a simple purchase, but anyone who has ended up with an uncomfortable pair that rides up, feels restrictive, or just doesn't look right knows that choosing shorts requires more thought than you might expect. Whether you're shopping for athletic performance, beach days, or everyday casual wear, understanding what to look for can save you time, money, and the frustration of ill-fitting shorts sitting unworn in your drawer.

This comprehensive guide will walk you through everything you need to consider when shopping for shorts, from understanding different styles and fabrics to finding the perfect fit for your body type and intended activities.

Understanding Different Shorts Styles

The first step in choosing the right shorts is understanding the main categories available. Each style is designed with specific activities and occasions in mind, and selecting the wrong type can lead to discomfort or inappropriate attire for the situation.

Athletic and Running Shorts

These shorts are designed for movement and moisture management. They typically feature lightweight, quick-drying fabrics and may include built-in briefs or compression liners. Athletic shorts usually have shorter inseams to allow unrestricted leg movement during exercise.

Board Shorts

Originally designed for surfing, board shorts are now popular for any beach or water activity. They feature longer inseams, quick-dry fabrics, and often include features like velcro fly closures and drain holes. Board shorts work well for swimming but can also transition to casual beachside settings.

Casual Shorts

These versatile shorts are designed for everyday wear. They come in various fabrics including cotton, linen, and blends, with different inseam lengths depending on current fashion trends. Casual shorts typically have a more structured appearance than athletic styles.

Cargo Shorts

Featuring additional pockets on the sides, cargo shorts offer extra storage capacity. While practical, they tend to add bulk to your silhouette, making them best suited for casual settings and outdoor activities where pocket space is genuinely useful.

Pro Tip

Consider building a small collection of shorts for different purposes rather than trying to find one pair that does everything. Having dedicated athletic, beach, and casual shorts means each pair can excel at its intended purpose.

Choosing the Right Inseam Length

Inseam length is one of the most important factors in how shorts look and feel. The inseam is measured from the crotch seam to the bottom hem of the shorts. Different lengths work better for different activities and body types.

  • Short (3-5 inches): Popular for running and athletic activities. Provides maximum leg freedom but shows more thigh. Works well for those with shorter legs or athletic builds.
  • Medium (6-7 inches): The most versatile length that works for most activities and body types. Sits above the knee and provides a balanced, classic look.
  • Long (8-10 inches): Typically reaches the knee or just below. Common for board shorts and cargo styles. Offers more coverage but can look dated or overwhelming on shorter individuals.

When trying on shorts, sit down and move around to ensure the length works for your activities. What looks good standing still may ride up uncomfortably when you sit or move.

Understanding Fabric Choices

The fabric of your shorts significantly affects comfort, durability, and performance. Here are the most common materials you'll encounter and their characteristics.

Cotton

Breathable and comfortable for casual wear, cotton shorts are soft against the skin and work well for everyday activities. However, cotton absorbs moisture and dries slowly, making it unsuitable for athletic use or water activities. Cotton also tends to wrinkle easily.

Polyester and Nylon

These synthetic materials are the foundation of most athletic shorts. They wick moisture away from the skin, dry quickly, and resist wrinkles. Modern polyester blends can feel quite soft while maintaining performance properties. They're excellent for workouts, running, and water activities.

Blends

Many shorts combine materials to achieve the best of multiple worlds. Cotton-polyester blends offer the comfort of cotton with improved durability and moisture management. Elastane (spandex) is often added to provide stretch and improve fit.

Key Takeaway
  • Choose cotton or linen for casual everyday wear in mild conditions
  • Select synthetic fabrics for athletic activities and water sports
  • Look for blends when you need versatility across multiple activities
  • Consider elastane content for shorts that need stretch

Getting the Right Fit

Beyond inseam length, several other fit factors determine how comfortable and flattering shorts will be. Pay attention to these elements when trying on shorts.

Waist Fit

Shorts should sit comfortably at your natural waist or hips depending on the style. You should be able to fit two fingers between the waistband and your body. Elastic waistbands offer flexibility and comfort, while fixed waistbands with belt loops provide a more structured look.

Thigh Room

The shorts should allow you to move freely without feeling restrictive. Sit down, squat, and take a few steps when trying them on. Athletic shorts typically offer more thigh room, while tailored casual shorts may fit more snugly.

Rise

The rise refers to the distance from the waistband to the crotch seam. Low-rise shorts sit below the natural waist, mid-rise at the waist, and high-rise above it. Your body type and comfort preferences will determine which rise works best for you.

Fit Check Checklist
  • Can you sit comfortably without the shorts pulling or riding up?
  • Is there enough room in the thighs for movement?
  • Does the waistband stay in place without a belt?
  • Can you squat without feeling restricted?
  • Do the shorts look proportional to your body type?

Special Features to Consider

Depending on how you plan to use your shorts, certain features can significantly enhance comfort and functionality.

  • Built-in Liner: Common in running shorts, liners provide support and reduce chafing. Some people love them, others prefer to wear their own underwear.
  • Pockets: Consider what you need to carry. Zip pockets secure valuables during activities, while deep pockets are convenient for casual wear.
  • Moisture-Wicking: Essential for athletic shorts, this technology pulls sweat away from your skin to keep you dry.
  • UPF Protection: For outdoor activities, UPF-rated fabric provides sun protection for your skin.
  • Reflective Elements: Important for runners or cyclists who may be active in low-light conditions.

Final Thoughts

Choosing the right shorts comes down to understanding your needs and preferences. Think about when and where you'll wear them most, what activities you'll do, and what fit makes you feel comfortable and confident. Don't be afraid to try on multiple pairs and move around in them before making a decision.

Remember that quality shorts are an investment. A well-made pair that fits properly and suits your needs will serve you better than multiple cheap pairs that never quite feel right. Take your time, consider the factors we've discussed, and you'll find shorts that become reliable favourites in your wardrobe.

For more specific advice, check out our guides on choosing running shorts and selecting the perfect board shorts for Australian beaches.